"Whatever you say, there is more liberty staying
along the China border than the Thai border," says Hein Naing. "There
is no abuse in China for workers who come and live legally in Ruili."
Win Myint, a Burmese who lives in Mae Sot, Thailand, says that
Burmese migrants do not find it easy to speak up when they have
problems or their rights are violated.
"Burmese people don't want to have problems, so they remain quiet
and end up being more oppressed," says Win Myint, who has lived
for about 20 years in Thailand and has published two Thai-Burmese
phrase books for migrants working along the border.
"It is their tradition that Burmese are afraid to go to the police.
If they go to a police station (in Thailand), the language (barrier)
will be difficult," Win Myint says, adding that they fear being
deported or becoming victims of extortion.
Pranom Somwong of the Chiang Mai-based Migrants Assistants Programme
says that the plight and perceptions of Burmese migrants in Thailand
are not helped by a lot of bad history between the two countries
and insensitive media reports that fan the flames of misunderstanding
and prejudice.
"I think English newspapers have more information about the problems
of migrant workers," said Pranom. "But the problem is in the Thai-language
media," which lacks information and understanding of Burmese migrant
labour in Thailand.
Still, she acknowledges that Thai reporting is now "more positive
and better than before" because also of non-government groups' efforts
to dialogue with the media.
Win Myint also notes that Thai textbooks still focus on Burmese
invasions of more than 100 years ago. He says that many younger
Thais would like to have good relations with neighbouring countries,
but century-old nationalistic attitudes remain popular in some circles.
"When we talk about patriotism in Burma, we talk only of the invading
British and the Japanese," he says. "But in Thai textbooks, they
only talk of Burma invading Thailand in the past."
But undocumented migration relates in the end to what the Burmese
government does. Win Myint says that if the the government were
to take a stand with the Thai government over the exploitation of
Burmese migrants, the situation could quickly improve.
But the Burmese government is the main reason for there being millions
of Burmese migrants outside the country in the first place. Social,
economic and political turmoil forces more and more Burmese across
the Thai and Chinese borders.
Burmese workers in both China and Thailand say they left for economic
reasons, but all say they would return home if and when the economic
situation improved in Burma.
"Working here is risky and frightening. If things were going well
in Burma, I would work there," says Nilar. "(But) What can I do?
I have to work in danger," she says.
Htun Shwe is feeling older. Life in Ruili is stable, but thinking
of himself as a foreign worker makes him uncomfortable. "Actually,
our native town is the best," he says. "I don't want to be here,
but it is the only option," he says.
Like many others, they cannot yet imagine their future lives, but
"one day" hope that they can return to their Burmese homes. (END/Copyright
IPS)